[Smgs1992]

personally i would go for a colorado. I had a 2002 nissan frontier that i sold with 190k on it. The truck had a good amount of rust despite being taken care of. The engine also took a noticeable decline in performance around the 170k mile mark. Interior wise was pretty spartan and the sound system was dreadful. Very hollow and tinny sound to it.
Now i understand what i had was a much older truck. However i recently had a loaner insurance provided me with that was a new frontier. Honestly it didnt seem like nissan had changed much of anything at all from the time i had mine. I was pretty disappointed and after a couple days with it called and asked if i could get something different. Ended up paying the difference for a F150 that i was much happier with.

I would highly suggest you do not get a frontier. The tacoma i have no experience with. Ive been in a colorado once and it wasnt bad. You could also opt to get a bigger truck and get a F150 with the ecoboost given your budget which i feel is a league above the trucks youre currently considering