That thing is sooooooo ugly I don't care if it was #1 and they were paying ME!
Can't say I have ever bought anything based on CR or really any kind of reliability ratings. Now certain brands have a reputation of being extra unreliable (MB, Fiat, Land Rover come to mind) and I might give second thought to buying a used one of those, but if I really wanted one I would probably still get a new one or a CPO or just lease it.
I feel like BMW is going through another Bangle Butt phase. Honestly some of them look ok... but some....